{
 "meta": {
  "date": "2026-07-02",
  "source": "tablebase/audit_out/*.json + tablebase/AUDIT.md (values copied verbatim, unmodified)",
  "ground_truth": "exact endgame tablebase, openness<=6, diff band +/-250, pro/pro, D=250, shells 0-6 complete",
  "protocol": "per participant: 2000 games vs each of {X188, CS_X181, S2} = 6000 games, pro/pro, alternating starters; every in-slice decision scored with exact action EVs; agreement is tie-aware (EV(best)-EV(chosen) < 1e-6); blunder = single decision forfeiting > 0.05 win prob"
 },
 "ranking": [
  {
   "participant": "IT3_ckpt0600",
   "lineage": "RL (PPO)",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 71961,
   "agreement": 0.7403593613207153,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.002267720396422588,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.02719790457449431,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.026119112255700676,
    0.028274980109841703
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.003752032350856714,
   "loss_max": 0.3679220093525908,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 23633,
      "agree": 0.72762662378877,
      "mean_loss": 0.0032867061479205806
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 24153,
      "agree": 0.7199519728398128,
      "mean_loss": 0.002325789076750765
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 24175,
      "agree": 0.7731954498448811,
      "mean_loss": 0.0012135643219192366
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 23466,
      "agree": 0.9015170885536521,
      "mean_loss": 0.0008042247193356944
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 10201,
      "agree": 0.8345260268601118,
      "mean_loss": 0.001561854463448506
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 38294,
      "agree": 0.6165195591998747,
      "mean_loss": 0.003352562093314781
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 474,
      "agree": 0.9641350210970464,
      "mean_loss": 0.001571154944893279
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 9006,
      "agree": 0.7630468576504552,
      "mean_loss": 0.0023554845414978315
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 12795,
      "agree": 0.6863618601016022,
      "mean_loss": 0.002423823768581
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 16089,
      "agree": 0.7195599477904158,
      "mean_loss": 0.002425228562710675
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 17011,
      "agree": 0.7498677326435835,
      "mean_loss": 0.0022325227795434773
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 16586,
      "agree": 0.7737248281683348,
      "mean_loss": 0.002002859867062397
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "X123",
   "lineage": "clean-slate",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 57655,
   "agreement": 0.5795681207180643,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.003318547364822499,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.03188847471980686,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.030048733653129347,
    0.03388303045517485
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.01151678085161738,
   "loss_max": 0.3524854020865913,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 19182,
      "agree": 0.5188718590345115,
      "mean_loss": 0.005340493856133281
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 19273,
      "agree": 0.5702277797955689,
      "mean_loss": 0.003106275034992614
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 19200,
      "agree": 0.6495833333333333,
      "mean_loss": 0.001511575855264577
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 17257,
      "agree": 0.6274555252940835,
      "mean_loss": 0.0023063900834956043
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 3114,
      "agree": 0.672125883108542,
      "mean_loss": 0.009593599041966444
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 37284,
      "agree": 0.5496727818903551,
      "mean_loss": 0.0032629279913977583
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 951,
      "agree": 0.3312302839116719,
      "mean_loss": 0.0031219562294959946
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 7680,
      "agree": 0.30690104166666665,
      "mean_loss": 0.008232639696760352
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 10127,
      "agree": 0.4189789671176064,
      "mean_loss": 0.003046836870115636
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 11410,
      "agree": 0.6374233128834356,
      "mean_loss": 0.003371803485506374
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 10692,
      "agree": 0.6049382716049383,
      "mean_loss": 0.0020552873941927906
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 16795,
      "agree": 0.7596903840428699,
      "mean_loss": 0.0020144368860656675
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "H1_Hoarder",
   "lineage": "clean-slate",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 45851,
   "agreement": 0.39015506750125406,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.00483362213014775,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.03693773471490075,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.03419254368926155,
    0.0397632822353589
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.02069747660901616,
   "loss_max": 0.49518108127773575,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 15668,
      "agree": 0.43860097013020166,
      "mean_loss": 0.006723759267178774
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 15238,
      "agree": 0.403596272476703,
      "mean_loss": 0.004455417816422339
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 14945,
      "agree": 0.325660756105721,
      "mean_loss": 0.003237664195691124
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 19181,
      "agree": 0.3967989155935561,
      "mean_loss": 0.006288398838451666
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 1309,
      "agree": 0.2589763177998472,
      "mean_loss": 0.028371225049249715
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 25361,
      "agree": 0.3919009502779859,
      "mean_loss": 0.00251846128226786
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 1766,
      "agree": 0.7123442808607021,
      "mean_loss": 0.003622214701121253
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 5942,
      "agree": 0.5843150454392461,
      "mean_loss": 0.007432047057081106
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 6320,
      "agree": 0.17990506329113923,
      "mean_loss": 0.0062536709066178435
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 6708,
      "agree": 0.45304114490161,
      "mean_loss": 0.0035196499722623363
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 7947,
      "agree": 0.35132754498552915,
      "mean_loss": 0.0034551039298812507
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 17168,
      "agree": 0.36061276794035413,
      "mean_loss": 0.0046876532175863005
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "X181",
   "lineage": "clean-slate",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 75053,
   "agreement": 0.6770548812172731,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.003194885948985377,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.039964295854866584,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.03785437370557595,
    0.042088830415681615
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.01172504763300601,
   "loss_max": 0.3521021724371698,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 24539,
      "agree": 0.667508863441868,
      "mean_loss": 0.004634326503054919
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 25493,
      "agree": 0.6940336562978072,
      "mean_loss": 0.003221018677047392
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 25021,
      "agree": 0.6691179409296191,
      "mean_loss": 0.0017565488164647965
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 21555,
      "agree": 0.8470424495476687,
      "mean_loss": 0.0011926804267451173
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 7443,
      "agree": 0.7510412468090824,
      "mean_loss": 0.006557258951925328
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 46055,
      "agree": 0.5855390294213441,
      "mean_loss": 0.003588576053664711
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 1149,
      "agree": 0.9147084421235857,
      "mean_loss": 0.0002946710688483521
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 13006,
      "agree": 0.5924957711825312,
      "mean_loss": 0.004942291940563124
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 13813,
      "agree": 0.5837254760008688,
      "mean_loss": 0.002471058327922799
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 15974,
      "agree": 0.6864905471391011,
      "mean_loss": 0.004144386320623896
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 13780,
      "agree": 0.7107402031930333,
      "mean_loss": 0.0027592194496498705
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 17331,
      "agree": 0.7636604927586406,
      "mean_loss": 0.0021239714561600473
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "X129",
   "lineage": "clean-slate",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 57974,
   "agreement": 0.5721875323420844,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.004431714406424293,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.042820701833007,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.040672045064110075,
    0.045014311355013874
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.016662641873943493,
   "loss_max": 0.35385759717542076,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 19111,
      "agree": 0.5096541258960808,
      "mean_loss": 0.0074043844227217985
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 19337,
      "agree": 0.5762527796452397,
      "mean_loss": 0.004008579973829166
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 19526,
      "agree": 0.6293659735736966,
      "mean_loss": 0.001941263409887898
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 17027,
      "agree": 0.6755740882128385,
      "mean_loss": 0.001987668935835252
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 5111,
      "agree": 0.6411661123067893,
      "mean_loss": 0.00902242459675773
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 35836,
      "agree": 0.5132269226476169,
      "mean_loss": 0.004938234175509164
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 984,
      "agree": 0.41971544715447157,
      "mean_loss": 0.004746025573456454
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 7319,
      "agree": 0.3533269572345949,
      "mean_loss": 0.011268957908435875
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 10609,
      "agree": 0.4460363842020926,
      "mean_loss": 0.0042674693555615
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 12765,
      "agree": 0.6199764982373678,
      "mean_loss": 0.003785937675672424
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 11066,
      "agree": 0.6243448400506054,
      "mean_loss": 0.0031172984092402325
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 15231,
      "agree": 0.6971308515527542,
      "mean_loss": 0.0027364925403555785
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "X168",
   "lineage": "clean-slate",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 75422,
   "agreement": 0.6294980244490997,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.0034190757051122144,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.04297892130516224,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.04062459574217783,
    0.04527483460110235
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.010925194240407308,
   "loss_max": 0.4430601725460166,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 24624,
      "agree": 0.6105019493177388,
      "mean_loss": 0.005024192584421196
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 25617,
      "agree": 0.6303626498028653,
      "mean_loss": 0.0034700675836457826
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 25181,
      "agree": 0.6471943131726302,
      "mean_loss": 0.0017975889893940633
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 21020,
      "agree": 0.85209324452902,
      "mean_loss": 0.0011483568329887187
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 7485,
      "agree": 0.7307949231796927,
      "mean_loss": 0.007288253212769301
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 46917,
      "agree": 0.5136091395443017,
      "mean_loss": 0.003819137879744493
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 1155,
      "agree": 0.4649350649350649,
      "mean_loss": 0.005295637445356028
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 14476,
      "agree": 0.4507460624481901,
      "mean_loss": 0.005796057707060437
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 13082,
      "agree": 0.5358507873413851,
      "mean_loss": 0.002420497997532405
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 16264,
      "agree": 0.6757870142646335,
      "mean_loss": 0.003957578056399645
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 13458,
      "agree": 0.700624164065983,
      "mean_loss": 0.002709223943410639
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 16987,
      "agree": 0.7644669453111202,
      "mean_loss": 0.002081685704995423
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "PS",
   "lineage": "baseline",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 46201,
   "agreement": 0.5191878963658795,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.006174519564200961,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.047544829730941436,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.043583877458583824,
    0.051121647272986424
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.024761368801541093,
   "loss_max": 0.5501755760415605,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 15955,
      "agree": 0.45691005954246317,
      "mean_loss": 0.010078695623418461
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 15505,
      "agree": 0.5140922283134473,
      "mean_loss": 0.00606585484672025
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 14741,
      "agree": 0.5919544128620854,
      "mean_loss": 0.0020631103938409602
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 27065,
      "agree": 0.5140217993718825,
      "mean_loss": 0.00504109488995193
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 2448,
      "agree": 0.5122549019607843,
      "mean_loss": 0.01149493728546069
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 16688,
      "agree": 0.5285834132310643,
      "mean_loss": 0.007232271015957088
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 12,
      "agree": 0.25,
      "mean_loss": 0.00022843074902606508
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 4272,
      "agree": 0.3780430711610487,
      "mean_loss": 0.007731697765605937
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 6066,
      "agree": 0.47543686119353773,
      "mean_loss": 0.004481381277555245
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 6266,
      "agree": 0.48005106926268754,
      "mean_loss": 0.008383388032821293
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 11480,
      "agree": 0.6056620209059234,
      "mean_loss": 0.006198864688820412
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 18105,
      "agree": 0.5260425296879315,
      "mean_loss": 0.005598403175422539
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "X147",
   "lineage": "clean-slate",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 66808,
   "agreement": 0.6354328822895462,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.00446095269246267,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.04967122124634101,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.04722537821302628,
    0.0521164869480166
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.01689917375164651,
   "loss_max": 0.3543857206521004,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 22117,
      "agree": 0.5810462540127503,
      "mean_loss": 0.007611270012757164
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 22270,
      "agree": 0.6343511450381679,
      "mean_loss": 0.0040738346050588495
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 22421,
      "agree": 0.6901565496632621,
      "mean_loss": 0.0017378605749625489
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 21273,
      "agree": 0.8444507121703568,
      "mean_loss": 0.0011841667306718938
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 7356,
      "agree": 0.6745513866231647,
      "mean_loss": 0.008419949062767364
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 38179,
      "agree": 0.5114329867204485,
      "mean_loss": 0.005523963522112841
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 842,
      "agree": 0.4358669833729216,
      "mean_loss": 0.005614169841087581
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 7763,
      "agree": 0.42019837691614065,
      "mean_loss": 0.011698247791011347
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 11466,
      "agree": 0.5025292168149311,
      "mean_loss": 0.004978036287802217
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 15642,
      "agree": 0.6664748753356349,
      "mean_loss": 0.004197001517675828
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 14157,
      "agree": 0.697322879141061,
      "mean_loss": 0.0026231838178962835
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 16938,
      "agree": 0.7535718502774826,
      "mean_loss": 0.002516390585951473
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "X159",
   "lineage": "clean-slate",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 66345,
   "agreement": 0.6394151782349838,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.0045838911706008525,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.05068637661891893,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.04836754350042541,
    0.05321966705326665
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.018494234682342302,
   "loss_max": 0.3543857206521004,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 21993,
      "agree": 0.592006547537853,
      "mean_loss": 0.00796552139686734
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 22121,
      "agree": 0.6366800777541702,
      "mean_loss": 0.0040871642152237155
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 22231,
      "agree": 0.6890378300571275,
      "mean_loss": 0.0017327330316785697
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 20397,
      "agree": 0.8567926655880767,
      "mean_loss": 0.0010977097601590892
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 7486,
      "agree": 0.6886187550093508,
      "mean_loss": 0.008073717948512853
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 38462,
      "agree": 0.5145598252820967,
      "mean_loss": 0.0057534299093386036
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 834,
      "agree": 0.4172661870503597,
      "mean_loss": 0.005231031055343853
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 7623,
      "agree": 0.40456513183785914,
      "mean_loss": 0.012932714949987125
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 11265,
      "agree": 0.5131824234354194,
      "mean_loss": 0.005282128942234103
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 16360,
      "agree": 0.67059902200489,
      "mean_loss": 0.004228643802791008
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 13555,
      "agree": 0.699151604573958,
      "mean_loss": 0.0027750463980537486
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 16708,
      "agree": 0.7637658606655494,
      "mean_loss": 0.0020870208688088506
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "X188",
   "lineage": "main",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 52415,
   "agreement": 0.6163121243918726,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.005944075333704809,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.051926451436022925,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.04937815812941365,
    0.054665638781112615
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.03420776495278069,
   "loss_max": 0.5418344855164481,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 17786,
      "agree": 0.6297087596986394,
      "mean_loss": 0.009591737482136408
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 17635,
      "agree": 0.6170683300255174,
      "mean_loss": 0.005651630726238166
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 16994,
      "agree": 0.6015064140284806,
      "mean_loss": 0.002429890426129769
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 22479,
      "agree": 0.6647537701855065,
      "mean_loss": 0.0029284890456786547
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 5333,
      "agree": 0.6122257641102569,
      "mean_loss": 0.011695651526618282
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 24603,
      "agree": 0.5729382595618421,
      "mean_loss": 0.007452599023162693
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 1301,
      "agree": 0.7194465795541891,
      "mean_loss": 0.006144569103928023
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 6647,
      "agree": 0.7857680156461562,
      "mean_loss": 0.004771348155701887
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 7066,
      "agree": 0.44098499858477214,
      "mean_loss": 0.0071102197461844424
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 8955,
      "agree": 0.629145728643216,
      "mean_loss": 0.009906047890281164
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 11183,
      "agree": 0.5601359205937584,
      "mean_loss": 0.0062401618211868045
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 17263,
      "agree": 0.6447894340497017,
      "mean_loss": 0.0036561589405455347
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "X109",
   "lineage": "main",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 51867,
   "agreement": 0.5732932307632984,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.006741908268676894,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.0582804260285774,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.055601057652080135,
    0.06109050237823501
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.040353211097615055,
   "loss_max": 0.5629060361997276,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 17582,
      "agree": 0.6038562165851439,
      "mean_loss": 0.010641291892962056
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 17483,
      "agree": 0.5697534748040954,
      "mean_loss": 0.006408544162337204
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 16802,
      "agree": 0.5449946434948221,
      "mean_loss": 0.0030083790334046088
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 23534,
      "agree": 0.6137078269737402,
      "mean_loss": 0.0032068469325282588
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 5043,
      "agree": 0.5657346817370613,
      "mean_loss": 0.013756906097408355
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 23290,
      "agree": 0.5340918849291542,
      "mean_loss": 0.008795042636844741
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 1006,
      "agree": 0.76441351888668,
      "mean_loss": 0.0070157319901017305
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 6828,
      "agree": 0.8140011716461628,
      "mean_loss": 0.004035553863101009
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 7117,
      "agree": 0.36321483771251933,
      "mean_loss": 0.008835726463199018
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 9044,
      "agree": 0.5243255196815568,
      "mean_loss": 0.012637186585749319
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 11581,
      "agree": 0.5124773335635956,
      "mean_loss": 0.006556099951201707
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 16291,
      "agree": 0.6227978638512062,
      "mean_loss": 0.0038038913361486217
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "S2",
   "lineage": "baseline",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 59456,
   "agreement": 0.43771864908503766,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.00998807156619378,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.09897513050660293,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.09429477390181705,
    0.10400749818001784
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.04626951022604951,
   "loss_max": 0.5018247708311678,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 20079,
      "agree": 0.3665521191294387,
      "mean_loss": 0.01748498483554374
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 19869,
      "agree": 0.42729880718707536,
      "mean_loss": 0.009292616483274051
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 19508,
      "agree": 0.5215808898913267,
      "mean_loss": 0.00298004796086542
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 44565,
      "agree": 0.4613710310782004,
      "mean_loss": 0.007941856518204005
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 6119,
      "agree": 0.3652557607452198,
      "mean_loss": 0.016496587313251723
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 8772,
      "agree": 0.3681030551755586,
      "mean_loss": 0.01584351681897728
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 23,
      "agree": 0.43478260869565216,
      "mean_loss": 0.005050339259714475
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 5174,
      "agree": 0.4284885968303054,
      "mean_loss": 0.011340587912713591
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 7837,
      "agree": 0.4661222406533112,
      "mean_loss": 0.010037243440212245
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 10037,
      "agree": 0.4559131214506327,
      "mean_loss": 0.013784238542748793
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 13644,
      "agree": 0.4605687481676928,
      "mean_loss": 0.009285406054534744
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 22741,
      "agree": 0.40829339079196164,
      "mean_loss": 0.008414496463377987
     }
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "participant": "E12",
   "lineage": "main",
   "n_games": 6000,
   "n_decisions": 60739,
   "agreement": 0.4321770197072721,
   "mean_ev_loss": 0.010266201582601024,
   "ev_lost_per_game": 0.10392646965426726,
   "ev_lost_per_game_ci95": [
    0.09900298734365812,
    0.10901571224568375
   ],
   "blunder_rate": 0.046839756993035775,
   "loss_max": 0.33613691129637946,
   "breakdown": {
    "by_darts": {
     "1": {
      "n": 20475,
      "agree": 0.3634188034188034,
      "mean_loss": 0.01786144977002139
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 20304,
      "agree": 0.42523640661938533,
      "mean_loss": 0.009626974996208043
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 19960,
      "agree": 0.5097695390781564,
      "mean_loss": 0.0031252271323350457
     }
    },
    "by_diff": {
     "behind": {
      "n": 45453,
      "agree": 0.4507953270411194,
      "mean_loss": 0.008343038694090251
     },
     "close": {
      "n": 6281,
      "agree": 0.3690495144085337,
      "mean_loss": 0.015852529871593943
     },
     "ahead": {
      "n": 9005,
      "agree": 0.38223209328151025,
      "mean_loss": 0.016076950587411192
     }
    },
    "by_openness": {
     "0": null,
     "1": {
      "n": 43,
      "agree": 0.6744186046511628,
      "mean_loss": 0.003986384425794968
     },
     "2": {
      "n": 5635,
      "agree": 0.4401064773735581,
      "mean_loss": 0.011086995482903225
     },
     "3": {
      "n": 8123,
      "agree": 0.4673150313923427,
      "mean_loss": 0.00978487358432969
     },
     "4": {
      "n": 10324,
      "agree": 0.44459511817125147,
      "mean_loss": 0.014433754079429708
     },
     "5": {
      "n": 13898,
      "agree": 0.4599942437760829,
      "mean_loss": 0.00944990777435487
     },
     "6": {
      "n": 22716,
      "agree": 0.3945236837471386,
      "mean_loss": 0.008851944020056714
     }
    }
   }
  }
 ],
 "hybrid_matches": {
  "X188": {
   "wins_hybrid": 27202,
   "games": 50000,
   "wr_hybrid": 0.54404,
   "se": 0.00223606797749979,
   "in_slice_darts_per_game": 7.54166,
   "clipped_darts": 3615,
   "total_darts": 1700250
  },
  "X181": {
   "wins_hybrid": 26768,
   "games": 50000,
   "wr_hybrid": 0.53536,
   "se": 0.00223606797749979,
   "in_slice_darts_per_game": 11.03784,
   "clipped_darts": 9624,
   "total_darts": 2554165
  },
  "X123": {
   "wins_hybrid": 25702,
   "games": 50000,
   "wr_hybrid": 0.51404,
   "se": 0.00223606797749979,
   "in_slice_darts_per_game": 9.53254,
   "clipped_darts": 62741,
   "total_darts": 5357490
  },
  "IT3_ckpt0600": {
   "wins_hybrid": 26378,
   "games": 50000,
   "wr_hybrid": 0.52756,
   "se": 0.00223606797749979,
   "in_slice_darts_per_game": 9.53038,
   "clipped_darts": 89,
   "total_darts": 1773404
  }
 }
}