{ "meta": { "date": "2026-07-02", "protocol": { "skill": "pro/pro", "first_thrower": "alternating (even game index: A first)", "c_engine": "fast_sim.so (this repo), run_batch, 4000 games/pair, seed 42", "python_engine": "Darts-Cricket-rl-cleanslate game.py via eval_pool.play_game, 1500 games/pair, stall guard 2000 darts (0 stalls observed)", "anchor": "S1 = 1000 Elo, scale 400/ln(10) per natural BT unit" }, "clean_slate_c_ports": { "note": "ids 230-236 in this repo's fast_sim.c, validated bit-identical to the fable-cleanslate engine on 28 matchups (4000 games each)", "mapping": { "230": "X123", "231": "X129", "232": "X147", "233": "X168", "234": "X181", "235": "X159", "236": "H1_Hoarder" } }, "python_port_validation": { "criterion": "port vs S2 within 1.5pp of the C number", "results_vs_S2_pp_diff": { "X123": 0.84, "X129": 0.7, "X147": 1.37, "X159": 0.55, "X168": 0.52, "X181": -1.02 }, "note": "X147/X159 first showed +2.1pp at 4000 games; re-run at 12000 games fresh seed gave +1.37/+0.55 \u2014 noise, not systematic. No ports dropped.", "dropped_ports": [] }, "bt_fit": "mean |observed \u2212 BT-predicted| edge error: 5.08pp; max: 16.53pp" }, "ladder": [ { "rank": 1, "name": "IT3", "elo": 1221.95, "se": 2.75, "games": 24000 }, { "rank": 2, "name": "IT2_det", "elo": 1215.72, "se": 2.74, "games": 24000 }, { "rank": 3, "name": "PPO_run2", "elo": 1205.8, "se": 2.72, "games": 24000 }, { "rank": 4, "name": "X181", "elo": 1175.55, "se": 1.68, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 5, "name": "X168", "elo": 1173.33, "se": 1.68, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 6, "name": "X159", "elo": 1167.15, "se": 1.68, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 7, "name": "X147", "elo": 1162.17, "se": 1.67, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 8, "name": "X129", "elo": 1135.06, "se": 1.66, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 9, "name": "X188", "elo": 1117.49, "se": 1.68, "games": 88000 }, { "rank": 10, "name": "X109", "elo": 1112.97, "se": 1.67, "games": 88000 }, { "rank": 11, "name": "X123", "elo": 1107.27, "se": 1.65, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 12, "name": "DIST", "elo": 1085.24, "se": 2.64, "games": 24000 }, { "rank": 13, "name": "X165", "elo": 1072.67, "se": 1.66, "games": 88000 }, { "rank": 14, "name": "X112", "elo": 1070.79, "se": 1.66, "games": 88000 }, { "rank": 15, "name": "H1_Hoarder", "elo": 1052.18, "se": 1.66, "games": 88000 }, { "rank": 16, "name": "S14", "elo": 1036.63, "se": 1.64, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 17, "name": "S10", "elo": 1031.67, "se": 1.64, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 18, "name": "E12", "elo": 1018.27, "se": 1.65, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 19, "name": "X103", "elo": 1018.25, "se": 1.67, "games": 88000 }, { "rank": 20, "name": "E10", "elo": 1013.69, "se": 1.67, "games": 88000 }, { "rank": 21, "name": "S2", "elo": 1013.58, "se": 1.65, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 22, "name": "E3", "elo": 1012.3, "se": 1.65, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 23, "name": "S1", "elo": 1000.0, "se": 0.0, "games": 88000 }, { "rank": 24, "name": "E1", "elo": 992.35, "se": 1.66, "games": 94000 }, { "rank": 25, "name": "E11", "elo": 989.72, "se": 1.68, "games": 88000 }, { "rank": 26, "name": "PS", "elo": 986.66, "se": 1.68, "games": 88000 }, { "rank": 27, "name": "S6", "elo": 949.53, "se": 1.68, "games": 94000 } ], "matches": [ { "a": "S1", "b": "S2", "wins_a": 1518, "wins_b": 2482, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "S6", "wins_a": 1667, "wins_b": 2333, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "S10", "wins_a": 1945, "wins_b": 2055, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "S14", "wins_a": 2076, "wins_b": 1924, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "E1", "wins_a": 1590, "wins_b": 2410, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "E3", "wins_a": 1465, "wins_b": 2535, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "E10", "wins_a": 1473, "wins_b": 2527, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "E11", "wins_a": 1732, "wins_b": 2268, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1471, "wins_b": 2529, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "PS", "wins_a": 1590, "wins_b": 2410, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 1443, "wins_b": 2557, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 1903, "wins_b": 2097, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 1856, "wins_b": 2144, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 1672, "wins_b": 2328, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1773, "wins_b": 2227, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1602, "wins_b": 2398, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1586, "wins_b": 2414, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1630, "wins_b": 2370, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1620, "wins_b": 2380, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1554, "wins_b": 2446, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1592, "wins_b": 2408, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S1", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1529, "wins_b": 2471, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "S6", "wins_a": 2253, "wins_b": 1747, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "S10", "wins_a": 2387, "wins_b": 1613, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "S14", "wins_a": 2267, "wins_b": 1733, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "E1", "wins_a": 2223, "wins_b": 1777, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "E3", "wins_a": 2003, "wins_b": 1997, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "E10", "wins_a": 1987, "wins_b": 2013, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "E11", "wins_a": 2361, "wins_b": 1639, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1990, "wins_b": 2010, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "PS", "wins_a": 1924, "wins_b": 2076, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 1948, "wins_b": 2052, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 1514, "wins_b": 2486, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 1437, "wins_b": 2563, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 1349, "wins_b": 2651, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1426, "wins_b": 2574, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1247, "wins_b": 2753, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1166, "wins_b": 2834, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1169, "wins_b": 2831, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1023, "wins_b": 2977, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1062, "wins_b": 2938, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1159, "wins_b": 2841, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S2", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1833, "wins_b": 2167, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "S10", "wins_a": 2062, "wins_b": 1938, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "S14", "wins_a": 2048, "wins_b": 1952, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "E1", "wins_a": 1985, "wins_b": 2015, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "E3", "wins_a": 1711, "wins_b": 2289, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "E10", "wins_a": 1670, "wins_b": 2330, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "E11", "wins_a": 2141, "wins_b": 1859, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1678, "wins_b": 2322, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "PS", "wins_a": 1825, "wins_b": 2175, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 1747, "wins_b": 2253, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 1016, "wins_b": 2984, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 988, "wins_b": 3012, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 912, "wins_b": 3088, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1022, "wins_b": 2978, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 981, "wins_b": 3019, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 809, "wins_b": 3191, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 623, "wins_b": 3377, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 532, "wins_b": 3468, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 550, "wins_b": 3450, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 602, "wins_b": 3398, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S6", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1594, "wins_b": 2406, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "S14", "wins_a": 2091, "wins_b": 1909, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "E1", "wins_a": 1564, "wins_b": 2436, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "E3", "wins_a": 1633, "wins_b": 2367, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "E10", "wins_a": 1691, "wins_b": 2309, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "E11", "wins_a": 1960, "wins_b": 2040, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1591, "wins_b": 2409, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "PS", "wins_a": 1750, "wins_b": 2250, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 1583, "wins_b": 2417, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 2036, "wins_b": 1964, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 1979, "wins_b": 2021, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 1940, "wins_b": 2060, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1864, "wins_b": 2136, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1772, "wins_b": 2228, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1711, "wins_b": 2289, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1784, "wins_b": 2216, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1712, "wins_b": 2288, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1728, "wins_b": 2272, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1771, "wins_b": 2229, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S10", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1902, "wins_b": 2098, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "E1", "wins_a": 1640, "wins_b": 2360, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "E3", "wins_a": 1719, "wins_b": 2281, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "E10", "wins_a": 1743, "wins_b": 2257, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "E11", "wins_a": 2118, "wins_b": 1882, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1649, "wins_b": 2351, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "PS", "wins_a": 1804, "wins_b": 2196, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 1668, "wins_b": 2332, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 2009, "wins_b": 1991, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 1943, "wins_b": 2057, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 1939, "wins_b": 2061, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1912, "wins_b": 2088, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1784, "wins_b": 2216, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1767, "wins_b": 2233, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1781, "wins_b": 2219, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1829, "wins_b": 2171, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1787, "wins_b": 2213, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1756, "wins_b": 2244, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "S14", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1884, "wins_b": 2116, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "E3", "wins_a": 1819, "wins_b": 2181, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "E10", "wins_a": 1794, "wins_b": 2206, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "E11", "wins_a": 2267, "wins_b": 1733, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1871, "wins_b": 2129, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "PS", "wins_a": 1909, "wins_b": 2091, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 1812, "wins_b": 2188, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 1370, "wins_b": 2630, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 1362, "wins_b": 2638, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 1289, "wins_b": 2711, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1370, "wins_b": 2630, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1160, "wins_b": 2840, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1009, "wins_b": 2991, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1036, "wins_b": 2964, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 926, "wins_b": 3074, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 938, "wins_b": 3062, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1016, "wins_b": 2984, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E1", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1459, "wins_b": 2541, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "E10", "wins_a": 2023, "wins_b": 1977, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "E11", "wins_a": 2284, "wins_b": 1716, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1987, "wins_b": 2013, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "PS", "wins_a": 1887, "wins_b": 2113, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 2022, "wins_b": 1978, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 1448, "wins_b": 2552, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 1462, "wins_b": 2538, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 1409, "wins_b": 2591, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1457, "wins_b": 2543, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1226, "wins_b": 2774, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1142, "wins_b": 2858, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1203, "wins_b": 2797, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1024, "wins_b": 2976, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1072, "wins_b": 2928, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1162, "wins_b": 2838, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E3", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1775, "wins_b": 2225, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "E11", "wins_a": 2266, "wins_b": 1734, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 2026, "wins_b": 1974, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "PS", "wins_a": 1951, "wins_b": 2049, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 2048, "wins_b": 1952, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 1445, "wins_b": 2555, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 1386, "wins_b": 2614, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 1358, "wins_b": 2642, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1447, "wins_b": 2553, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1318, "wins_b": 2682, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1196, "wins_b": 2804, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1138, "wins_b": 2862, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 987, "wins_b": 3013, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1030, "wins_b": 2970, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1113, "wins_b": 2887, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E10", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1670, "wins_b": 2330, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1658, "wins_b": 2342, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "PS", "wins_a": 1951, "wins_b": 2049, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 1697, "wins_b": 2303, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 1473, "wins_b": 2527, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 1432, "wins_b": 2568, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 1524, "wins_b": 2476, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1457, "wins_b": 2543, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1322, "wins_b": 2678, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1301, "wins_b": 2699, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1171, "wins_b": 2829, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1235, "wins_b": 2765, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1161, "wins_b": 2839, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1202, "wins_b": 2798, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E11", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1560, "wins_b": 2440, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "PS", "wins_a": 1983, "wins_b": 2017, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 2020, "wins_b": 1980, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 1465, "wins_b": 2535, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 1490, "wins_b": 2510, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 1466, "wins_b": 2534, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1474, "wins_b": 2526, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1278, "wins_b": 2722, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1223, "wins_b": 2777, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1189, "wins_b": 2811, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1053, "wins_b": 2947, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1091, "wins_b": 2909, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1215, "wins_b": 2785, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "E12", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1814, "wins_b": 2186, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X103", "wins_a": 2038, "wins_b": 1962, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 1058, "wins_b": 2942, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 979, "wins_b": 3021, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 977, "wins_b": 3023, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1029, "wins_b": 2971, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1394, "wins_b": 2606, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1321, "wins_b": 2679, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 818, "wins_b": 3182, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 658, "wins_b": 3342, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 626, "wins_b": 3374, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 765, "wins_b": 3235, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PS", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1551, "wins_b": 2449, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "X109", "wins_a": 1478, "wins_b": 2522, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 1514, "wins_b": 2486, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 1409, "wins_b": 2591, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1442, "wins_b": 2558, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1212, "wins_b": 2788, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1197, "wins_b": 2803, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1209, "wins_b": 2791, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1051, "wins_b": 2949, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1043, "wins_b": 2957, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1228, "wins_b": 2772, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X103", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 1815, "wins_b": 2185, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X109", "b": "X112", "wins_a": 2638, "wins_b": 1362, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X109", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 2737, "wins_b": 1263, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X109", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1966, "wins_b": 2034, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X109", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1989, "wins_b": 2011, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X109", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1790, "wins_b": 2210, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X109", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1855, "wins_b": 2145, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X109", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1822, "wins_b": 2178, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X109", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1830, "wins_b": 2170, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X109", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1875, "wins_b": 2125, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X109", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 2305, "wins_b": 1695, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X112", "b": "X165", "wins_a": 2048, "wins_b": 1952, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X112", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1321, "wins_b": 2679, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X112", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1953, "wins_b": 2047, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X112", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1730, "wins_b": 2270, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X112", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1083, "wins_b": 2917, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X112", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1056, "wins_b": 2944, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X112", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1094, "wins_b": 2906, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X112", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1135, "wins_b": 2865, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X112", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 2301, "wins_b": 1699, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X165", "b": "X188", "wins_a": 1261, "wins_b": 2739, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X165", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1923, "wins_b": 2077, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X165", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1770, "wins_b": 2230, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X165", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1050, "wins_b": 2950, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X165", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1070, "wins_b": 2930, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X165", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1019, "wins_b": 2981, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X165", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1091, "wins_b": 2909, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X165", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 2339, "wins_b": 1661, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X188", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1976, "wins_b": 2024, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X188", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1722, "wins_b": 2278, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X188", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1845, "wins_b": 2155, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X188", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1879, "wins_b": 2121, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X188", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1816, "wins_b": 2184, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X188", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1853, "wins_b": 2147, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X188", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 2286, "wins_b": 1714, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X123", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 1780, "wins_b": 2220, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X123", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1559, "wins_b": 2441, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X123", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1521, "wins_b": 2479, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X123", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1532, "wins_b": 2468, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X123", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1525, "wins_b": 2475, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X123", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 2037, "wins_b": 1963, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X129", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 1769, "wins_b": 2231, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X129", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1793, "wins_b": 2207, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X129", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1739, "wins_b": 2261, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X129", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1754, "wins_b": 2246, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X129", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 2266, "wins_b": 1734, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X147", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 1907, "wins_b": 2093, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X147", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1930, "wins_b": 2070, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X147", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1939, "wins_b": 2061, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X147", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 2767, "wins_b": 1233, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X168", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 1975, "wins_b": 2025, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X168", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1958, "wins_b": 2042, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X168", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 2789, "wins_b": 1211, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X181", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 1996, "wins_b": 2004, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X181", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 2825, "wins_b": 1175, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "X159", "b": "H1_Hoarder", "wins_a": 2819, "wins_b": 1181, "games": 4000, "engine": "C", "seed": 42 }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "S2", "wins_a": 1245, "wins_b": 255, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "S6", "wins_a": 1348, "wins_b": 152, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "S10", "wins_a": 890, "wins_b": 610, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "S14", "wins_a": 873, "wins_b": 627, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "E1", "wins_a": 1223, "wins_b": 277, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "E3", "wins_a": 1287, "wins_b": 213, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1229, "wins_b": 271, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 975, "wins_b": 525, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 858, "wins_b": 642, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 848, "wins_b": 652, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 807, "wins_b": 693, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 843, "wins_b": 657, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 821, "wins_b": 679, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "S2", "wins_a": 1198, "wins_b": 302, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "S6", "wins_a": 1344, "wins_b": 156, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "S10", "wins_a": 933, "wins_b": 567, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "S14", "wins_a": 901, "wins_b": 599, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "E1", "wins_a": 1243, "wins_b": 257, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "E3", "wins_a": 1252, "wins_b": 248, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1216, "wins_b": 284, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 1012, "wins_b": 488, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 876, "wins_b": 624, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 906, "wins_b": 594, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 841, "wins_b": 659, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 890, "wins_b": 610, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 854, "wins_b": 646, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "S2", "wins_a": 1226, "wins_b": 274, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "S6", "wins_a": 1356, "wins_b": 144, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "S10", "wins_a": 902, "wins_b": 598, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "S14", "wins_a": 868, "wins_b": 632, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "E1", "wins_a": 1230, "wins_b": 270, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "E3", "wins_a": 1271, "wins_b": 229, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 1202, "wins_b": 298, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 980, "wins_b": 520, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 886, "wins_b": 614, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 883, "wins_b": 617, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 849, "wins_b": 651, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 905, "wins_b": 595, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 900, "wins_b": 600, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "S2", "wins_a": 882, "wins_b": 618, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "S6", "wins_a": 1063, "wins_b": 437, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "S10", "wins_a": 874, "wins_b": 626, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "S14", "wins_a": 874, "wins_b": 626, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "E1", "wins_a": 835, "wins_b": 665, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "E3", "wins_a": 934, "wins_b": 566, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "E12", "wins_a": 912, "wins_b": 588, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "X123", "wins_a": 597, "wins_b": 903, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "X129", "wins_a": 553, "wins_b": 947, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "X147", "wins_a": 575, "wins_b": 925, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "X159", "wins_a": 568, "wins_b": 932, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "X168", "wins_a": 565, "wins_b": 935, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "DIST", "b": "X181", "wins_a": 572, "wins_b": 928, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "IT2_det", "wins_a": 707, "wins_b": 793, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "IT3", "wins_a": 617, "wins_b": 883, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "PPO_run2", "b": "DIST", "wins_a": 986, "wins_b": 514, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "IT3", "wins_a": 683, "wins_b": 817, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT2_det", "b": "DIST", "wins_a": 931, "wins_b": 569, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" }, { "a": "IT3", "b": "DIST", "wins_a": 911, "wins_b": 589, "stalls": 0, "games": 1500, "engine": "python" } ] }